Quick Answer
Asking for a salary range, not just one number, can help you earn more. Research reveals that the higher end of your suggested range acts as a mental cue, nudging negotiations towards a better pay packet. It’s a clever tactic to secure a more favourable deal.
In a hurry? TL;DR
- 1Propose a salary range with your target as the lowest figure (bolstering range) to anchor negotiations higher.
- 2Offering a range appears flexible and reasonable, paradoxically increasing your negotiation leverage.
- 3The higher end of your range acts as a psychological anchor, pulling the final offer upward.
- 4Avoid naming a single salary figure, as research shows it can limit your potential earnings.
- 5Use the bolstering range strategy to transform salary negotiations into a collaborative, financially beneficial process.
- 6This tactic avoids defensive reactions often triggered by aggressive single-figure demands.
Why It Matters
It's surprising that offering a salary range, rather than a single figure, can actually lead to higher pay due to psychological anchoring.
Negotiators who propose a specific salary range often secure significantly higher pay than those who name a single, fixed figure. This tactic, known as the bolstering range offer, leverages psychological anchoring to pull the final agreement toward the higher end of the spectrum.
The Strategy at a Glance
- The Bolstering Range: Setting your target number as the floor of the range, rather than the midpoint or ceiling.
- The Flexibility Paradox: Offering a range makes you appear more reasonable and cooperative, which ironically gives you more leverage.
- Anchoring Effect: The top number in your range serves as a psychological anchor that shifts the entire conversation upward.
- Counter-Intuition: Traditional advice suggests a single number shows strength; science suggests it actually limits your potential gains.
Why It Matters
Mastering the range offer transforms a negotiation from a tug-of-war into a collaborative problem-solving exercise where you still come out on top financially.
The Discovery of the Bolstering Range
For decades, the standard advice in Columbia Business School seminars and corporate workshops was to pick a number and stick to it. The logic was simple: providing a range supposedly invited the employer to choose the lowest possible figure.
However, researchers Malia Mason and Daniel Ames changed this perspective through a series of studies published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. They discovered that not all ranges are created equal.
The researchers identified three types of ranges: the bracing range (where your target is the high end), the hovering range (where your target is the midpoint), and the bolstering range (where your target is the bottom). Their data revealed that the bolstering range was the clear winner for the employee.
How the Psychology Works
The success of the range offer comes down to two distinct psychological drivers: anchoring and politeness.
When you offer a range like 70,000 to 80,000 pounds, the higher number acts as a powerful anchor. Even if the employer cannot reach the 80,000 mark, the presence of that number pulls their counter-offer higher than if you had simply asked for 70,000.
Unlike other aggressive negotiation tactics, the range offer does not trigger the defensive response often seen with high-ball single figures. Because you are technically offering multiple options, you are perceived as flexible and empathetic.
According to researchers at Columbia, this perceived reasonableness makes the other party more likely to concede. They feel less like they are being pushed and more like they are participating in a fair exchange.
Practical Applications
- New Job Offers: When asked for your salary expectations, provide a range where the bottom number is the salary you actually want to earn.
- Freelance Quoting: When pitching a project, offer a price range based on complexity. This allows you to capture a higher fee if the scope creeps.
- Annual Reviews: Use a range to signal that you are open to different compensation structures, such as bonuses or equity, while keeping the base salary anchor high.
Interesting Connections
- Etymology: The word negotiation comes from the Latin negotium, literally meaning not leisure. It implies the active, often difficult work of business.
- Cultural Differences: In contrast to the directness preferred in US or UK business cultures, many Middle Eastern and Asian cultures have used range-based bargaining as a social norm for centuries.
- The Price Tag History: Fixed pricing is a relatively recent invention, popularized by Quaker merchants like John Wanamaker who believed it was dishonest to charge different people different prices.
Key Takeaways
- Propose a bolstering range where your ideal salary is the floor, not the ceiling.
- Use the higher number in your range to anchor the employer's expectations upward.
- Leverage the perception of flexibility to make the employer more willing to concede.
- Avoid the bracing range, as it leads to lower settlements by making your target the best-case scenario rather than the baseline.
By shifting from a single figure to a calculated range, you move from a position of demand to a position of collaboration, almost always resulting in a better deal for your bank account.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & References
- 1Journal of Counseling PsychologyA study by Malia Mason and Daniel Ames, published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, identifies the 'bolstering range offer' as a negotiation tactic where the target number is presented as the bottom of a range.psycnet.apa.org
- 2Columbia Business SchoolProfessor Malia Mason's research at Columbia Business School highlights the counter-intuitive finding that offering a range can be more effective than a single number in salary negotiations, particularly when using a bolstering range.www8.gsb.columbia.edu
- 3Columbia Business SchoolResearch conducted by Columbia Business School found that job candidates who offer a salary range, especially a bolstering range, tend to receive significantly higher offers than those who state a single figure.www8.gsb.columbia.edu
