Skip to content
    Man and woman discussing problem vs. solution, illustrating article's core message.

    "Problem talk creates problems, Solution talk creates solutions."

    Steve de Shazer
    Last updated: Monday 7th October 2024

    In a hurry? TL;DR

    • 1Focus conversation on desired future outcomes, not past problems, to foster solutions.
    • 2Shift from analyzing 'what's broken' to envisioning 'what works' for progress.
    • 3Language shapes reality; choose solution-oriented words to create positive change.
    • 4Identify and amplify existing exceptions and strengths, rather than dwelling on deficits.
    • 5Solution-focused approaches are often more efficient than problem-centric therapies.
    • 6Ask 'what does success look like?' instead of 'why is this a problem?'

    Why It Matters

    Focusing your conversation on what you want to achieve rather than what's gone wrong can actually lead you there more effectively.

    Steve de Shazer’s principle suggests that the language we use does not just describe our reality; it creates it. By shifting focus from the history of a deficit to the architecture of a resolution, we change the cognitive framework of the situation itself.

    The Core Idea

    Focusing on why something is broken often tethers you to the damage, whereas discussing what a fixed state looks like builds a bridge toward it. Solution talk treats the future as a negotiable space rather than a consequence of the past.

    Why It Matters

    This insight flips the traditional diagnostic model on its head. Instead of playing archaeologist with your failures, you become an architect of your progress. It suggests that insight into a problem is not a prerequisite for change.

    The Architecture of Conversation

    Steve de Shazer was not merely offering a motivational platitude. As a pioneer of Solution-Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT), he observed that the more time clients spent describing their misery, the more expert they became at being miserable. In contrast to Freudian models that spend years digging for childhood roots, de Shazer found that change often happens independently of the problem’s origin.

    In the 1980s at the Brief Family Therapy Center in Milwaukee, de Shazer and Insoo Kim Berg noticed a pattern: clients who focused on exceptions—times when the problem was absent—recovered faster than those who dissected the problem. This led to the famous Miracle Question, asking clients to describe their life if they woke up and the problem had vanished overnight.

    Unlike the deep-dive approach of psychoanalysis, solution talk relies on identifying what is already working. It assumes that the client possesses the necessary resources but has been blinded by the narrative weight of their struggle. By changing the vocabulary, you change the map.

    About the Author

    Practical Applications

    • Workplace Conflict: Instead of asking why a deadline was missed, ask what specific actions would ensure the next one is met with ease.
    • Personal Growth: Replace the question Why am I so anxious? with What does a calm afternoon look like for me, and what is the first step toward it?
    • Parenting: Focus less on the mechanics of a tantrum and more on identifying the moments when the child successfully managed their frustration.
    • The Miracle Question: A technique used to help people envision a future without their current problem.
    • Neuroplasticity: The physical way the brain rewires itself based on repeated thought patterns and language.
    • Appreciative Inquiry: An organisational strategy that focuses on strengths rather than weaknesses.

    Does this mean we should ignore problems entirely?

    No. It means acknowledging the problem briefly to define the goal, then pivoting quickly to the mechanics of the solution to avoid becoming stuck in a cycle of rumination.

    How does this differ from positive thinking?

    Positive thinking is about mood and optimism; solution talk is about specific, actionable language and identifying concrete exceptions to the problem.

    Can this work for complex trauma?

    While complex issues require nuanced care, the principle remains: focusing on a person’s resilience and their life beyond the trauma often yields more functional progress than constant re-traumatisation through retelling.

    Key Takeaways

    • Language creates reality: How you describe a situation dictates how you interact with it.
    • Focus on exceptions: Look for times when the problem was absent and replicate those conditions.
    • Look forward: Spend less time on the why and more time on the how.
    • Small steps: Identify the smallest possible sign of progress to build momentum.

    Historical Context

    This quote by Steve de Shazer, a pioneering American psychotherapist, underpins the philosophy of Solution-Focused Brief Therapy (SFBT). Developed in the late 20th century, SFBT marked a radical shift from traditional psychological approaches, such as Freudian psychoanalysis, which emphasised deep exploration of past traumas and problem origins. De Shazer, alongside Insoo Kim Berg, argued that understanding the 'why' of a problem is often unnecessary for its resolution. This perspective arose from observations that extensive 'problem talk' can inadvertently solidify a problem, making it seem more entrenched and difficult to overcome.

    Meaning & Interpretation

    De Shazer's quote means that the language and focus of our discussions directly influence the outcomes we achieve. If we dwell on the details, history, and perceived causes of an issue ('problem talk'), we inadvertently reinforce its presence and complexity. Conversely, by shifting our conversation to what we want to achieve, future possibilities, and practical steps for moving forward ('solution talk'), we proactively construct pathways to resolution. It suggests that focusing on remedies and desired states, rather than dissecting difficulties, is a more efficient and effective way to overcome challenges.

    When to Use This Quote

    This quote is highly relevant in situations requiring a practical, forward-looking approach to challenges. It's particularly useful in coaching, therapy, and team meetings where discussions risk becoming bogged down in blame or historical analysis. Apply it when you want to steer a conversation from dwelling on obstacles to identifying actionable steps and desired outcomes. It's excellent for fostering a positive, proactive mindset, encouraging people to focus on 'how to move forward' rather than 'why we're stuck'.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The core idea is that focusing on the problem itself keeps you stuck, while focusing on what a solution looks like helps you move towards it. Language doesn't just describe reality; it shapes it.

    Solution talk shifts focus from diagnosing the root of a problem to identifying what's already working and envisioning a desired future state. It assumes individuals have resources and change can happen without fully understanding the problem's origin.

    The Miracle Question is a technique where clients are asked to imagine their lives if their problem vanished overnight. It's a practical application of solution talk, encouraging a focus on positive future outcomes.

    Solution talk can be applied to workplace conflicts by focusing on future deadlines, personal growth by envisioning calm, and parenting by highlighting moments of successful frustration management.

    Sources & References