Skip to content
    Man embracing imperfection, striving for progress over unattainable perfection.

    "Perfect is the enemy of good."

    Voltaire
    Last updated: Sunday 13th October 2024

    In a hurry? TL;DR

    • 1Perfectionism often leads to paralysis, preventing the completion of 'good enough' work.
    • 2Striving for absolute flawlessness can stall progress and kill productivity, as per Voltaire's insight.
    • 3Recognize diminishing returns; the final effort for perfection often yields little added value (Pareto Principle).
    • 4Embrace iteration and feedback over waiting for an unattainable perfect state.
    • 5Shipping a flawed but functional product is more valuable than holding onto a perfect idea indefinitely.
    • 6Fear of judgment often masquerades as a pursuit of perfection; aim for excellence instead.

    Why It Matters

    It's surprisingly useful to realise that aiming for absolute perfection can actually stop you from getting anything done at all.

    Voltaire’s most famous aphorism argues that the pursuit of an unattainable ideal often prevents us from achieving a functional reality. It suggests that obsessing over flawlessness is a form of paralysis that kills productivity and progress.

    • Perfectionism as paralysis: Striving for the best often stalls the completion of the good.
    • Voltaire’s origin: Popularised in his 1770 poem La Bégueule as le mieux est l’ennemi du bien.
    • The Pareto Principle: The final 20 percent of effort often takes 80 percent of the time for diminishing returns.
    • Iteration over stagnation: Completed work allows for feedback, while unfinished perfection offers nothing.

    Why It Matters

    In an era of curated social feeds and high-pressure productivity, this quote serves as a psychological handbrake, reminding us that shipping a flawed product is infinitely more valuable than harbouring a perfect idea.

    The Tyranny of the Ideal

    Voltaire did not invent the sentiment, but he gave it the sharp, clinical edge that allowed it to survive three centuries. Writing in his 1770 philosophical poem La Bégueule, he adapted an Italian proverb to critique those who are never satisfied.

    The core tension lies in the distinction between excellence and perfection. Excellence is a high standard of quality; perfection is a defensive crouch. When we claim we are waiting for something to be perfect, we are usually just afraid of being judged.

    The Cost of the Last Percent

    Economists often view this through the lens of diminishing returns. In software development, the term gold plating describes the practice of continuing to work on a project past the point where extra effort adds any real value.

    While Voltaire used it in a moral and social context, the principle is now a cornerstone of modern engineering. According to researchers at the University of California, perfectionist tendencies are actually linked to lower levels of innovation because the fear of making a mistake outweighs the drive to experiment.

    Putting Good to Work

    Applying this requires a shift from a destination mindset to an iterative one. If you are writing a book, a finished draft that needs editing is good; a perfect opening chapter that never goes further is a failure.

    In clinical settings, such as the development of vaccines, scientists must often balance the need for high efficacy with the urgent need for distribution. A 90 percent effective vaccine available today saves more lives than a 100 percent effective one available in three years.

    About the Author

    Connections and Contrasts

    • The Nirvana Fallacy: A logical fallacy where people reject a solution because it is not perfect, even if it is better than the alternatives.
    • Winston Churchill: He famously adapted the quote during World War II, stating that perfection is spelled paralysis.
    • Wabi-sabi: In contrast to Western perfectionism, this Japanese aesthetic finds beauty in imperfection and transience.

    Does this quote encourage laziness?

    No. It encourages completion. The goal is to reach a high standard of quality that functions in the real world rather than staying stuck in a theoretical loop of endless refinement.

    Who actually said it first?

    While Voltaire popularised the phrase in 1770, he credited it as an Italian proverb. Similar sentiments appear in the works of Aristotle and Shakespeare, who wrote in King Lear: Striving to better, oft we mar what's well.

    Is there ever a time when perfect is necessary?

    In high-stakes fields like aerospace engineering or neurosurgery, the tolerance for error is near zero. However, even in these fields, the enemy of good refers to the specific danger of over-engineering a solution until it becomes impractical or unusable.

    Key Takeaways

    • Done is better than perfect: A finished project can be improved; an unfinished one is useless.
    • Avoid the polish trap: Identify the point where additional effort no longer provides meaningful value.
    • Value iteration: Use the good as a baseline to eventually reach the great through feedback and updates.

    Historical Context

    This timeless aphorism, "Perfect is the enemy of good," was popularised by Voltaire in his 1770 philosophical poem, 'La Bégueule'. The original French, 'Le mieux est l'ennemi du bien,' translates to 'the best is the enemy of the good'. Although Voltaire is credited with its widespread recognition, the underlying sentiment existed in earlier Italian proverbs. It emerged during an era of enlightenment, reflecting a pragmatic observation on human nature and productivity, rather than advocating for mediocrity. Voltaire used it to critique the pursuit of an ideal that often impedes practical progress.

    Meaning & Interpretation

    The quote warns against the debilitating effects of perfectionism. It means that striving for an unattainable or excessively polished ideal can prevent us from completing tasks or achieving valuable, functional outcomes. By constantly seeking flawlessness, individuals risk overthinking, procrastination, and ultimately, stagnation. It highlights that an 'adequate' or 'good enough' solution, project, or product that is completed and implemented is often far superior to a theoretically 'perfect' one that never materialises. Accepting 'good' lowers the barrier to action, allowing for progress and iteration.

    When to Use This Quote

    This quote is highly relevant in various practical situations. It's particularly useful when launching new projects or products, advising against endless revisions that delay release. In creative fields, it encourages artists and writers to complete drafts rather than getting stuck on initial details. For students, it's a reminder to submit assignments that are 'good' rather than missing deadlines due to striving for an impossible 'perfect' grade. In agile development, it supports the principle of shipping a Minimum Viable Product (MVP). It's also applicable in personal development, to overcome procrastination driven by fear of inadequacy.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Voltaire's quote means that striving for an unattainable ideal of perfection can prevent you from achieving a functional or satisfactory outcome. Obsessing over flawlessness can lead to paralysis, hindering progress and productivity.

    The quote was popularized by Voltaire in his 1770 poem La Bégueule, where it appeared as "le mieux est l’ennemi du bien." He adapted an existing Italian proverb, "Il meglio è l'inimico del bene."

    Perfectionism can lead to paralysis because the fear of not achieving flawlessness can prevent you from starting or finishing a task. This constant striving for the best often stalls the completion of something that is already good or functional.

    Perfectionist tendencies can be linked to lower levels of innovation. The fear of making mistakes associated with perfectionism can outweigh the drive to experiment and create something new.

    Sources & References