Skip to content
    Person learning from a past mistake, turning into a wise decision.

    "Good judgment comes from experience, and a lot of that comes from bad judgment."

    Will Rogers
    Last updated: Tuesday 8th September 2026

    In a hurry? TL;DR

    • 1Embrace failure as essential tuition for developing good judgment and future competence.
    • 2Recognize that wisdom is earned through trial and error, not just theoretical knowledge.
    • 3Reframe embarrassing missteps as necessary prerequisites for eventual mastery and success.
    • 4View past mistakes as valuable learning experiences, rather than reasons for shame.
    • 5Understand that good judgment develops by experiencing and learning from poor decisions.
    • 6Hire and learn from individuals with 'scars' on their resumes, signifying paid-for lessons.

    Why It Matters

    It's surprisingly useful to know that our mistakes are actually how we learn to make better decisions in the future.

    Good judgment is the ability to make sound decisions based on past events, yet those events are almost always the result of initial, poorly calculated risks. Will Rogers suggests that wisdom is not an innate gift but a recycled product of our own failures.

    The Gist

    • Wisdom: True insight is earned through trial and error, not theoretical study.
    • Resilience: Failure is the raw material required to manufacture success.
    • Perspective: Past mistakes are tuition payments for future competence.
    • Authenticity: Admitting to bad judgment is the first step toward gaining its opposite.

    Why It Matters

    This quote serves as a powerful antidote to perfectionism, reframing every embarrassing misstep as a necessary prerequisite for eventual mastery.

    What the Quote Means

    Will Rogers captures the cyclical nature of human intelligence. We crave the end result—good judgment—but we often attempt to bypass the messy middle ground of being wrong. Unlike academic knowledge, which can be memorised, judgment is a muscle that only grows when it is strained by the consequences of a bad call.

    The tension lies in the price of admission. To be the person who knows what to do in a crisis, you likely had to be the person who caused one in your twenties. It is an ironic loop: you cannot have the virtue without first possessing the vice of ignorance.

    About the Author

    Will Rogers was an American humorist, social commentator, and vaudeville performer known as Oklahomas Favourite Son. He was one of the most famous celebrities of the 1920s and 30s, renowned for his sharp wit and common-sense philosophy.

    Historical Context

    Rogers delivered this observation during an era of rapid American expansion and economic volatility. In the early 20th century, the rugged individualism of the frontier was colliding with a new, professionalised corporate world. Rogers reminded his audience that no matter how many degrees or titles one held, the fundamental mechanism of human learning remained unchanged since the days of the Wild West: you touch the stove to learn it is hot.

    Practical Applications

    • Executive Leadership: Hire for the scars on a resume, not just the accolades, as they represent lessons already paid for.
    • Personal Growth: Replace the shame of a bad decision with the intellectual curiosity of a post-mortem analysis.
    • Risk Management: Recognise that avoiding all bad judgment creates a vacuum where good judgment can never develop.

    Similar Perspectives

    • Samuel Beckett: Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better.
    • Oscar Wilde: Experience is simply the name we give our mistakes.
    • Contrary View: Some argue that vicarious learning—studying the failures of others—is a more efficient path to wisdom than making the mistakes yourself.

    Who originally said this quote?

    While often attributed to various figures like Mark Twain or Rita Mae Brown, the phrasing is most consistently linked to Will Rogers, the American humorist.

    Does this mean we should seek out bad decisions?

    No. It suggests we should not be paralysed by the fear of them. The goal is to act with the best information available, knowing that even a failure provides the data needed for the next attempt.

    How does bad judgment lead to good judgment?

    Through a process called reflective practice. When a decision fails, the brain is forced to re-evaluate its heuristics and assumptions, creating a more sophisticated mental model for the future.

    Key Takeaways

    • Experience: The bridge between being a novice and being an expert.
    • Reframing: Stop seeing mistakes as dead ends and start seeing them as data points.
    • Patience: Wisdom is a slow-cooked virtue that cannot be rushed or faked.

    Learn more about the psychology of decision making, the growth mindset, and how to master your ego.

    Historical Context

    This well-known observation by Will Rogers, the renowned American cowboy, comedian, and social commentator of the early 20th century, succinctly captures a fundamental aspect of human learning. Rogers, famous for his wit and folksy wisdom, often presented profound truths in an accessible manner. The quote suggests that practical wisdom, or 'good judgment', isn't an inherent quality or something acquired purely through academic study, but rather a hard-won attribute. It reflects a world where experience, often gained through trial and error, was highly valued, especially in professions or life situations where theoretical knowledge alone was insufficient for effective decision-making.

    Meaning & Interpretation

    In plain terms, this quote means that sound decision-making abilities, or 'good judgment', are primarily developed through direct experience. Crucially, a significant portion of this valuable experience comes from making mistakes or exhibiting 'bad judgment' in the past. It posits that errors, failures, or miscalculations are not merely setbacks but essential learning opportunities. Instead of viewing bad judgment as a definitive flaw, Rogers suggests it's a necessary precursor, a sort of tuition fee, for acquiring the wisdom needed to make better choices in the future. It highlights a cyclical process where failure informs future success.

    When to Use This Quote

    This quote is highly relevant when discussing personal and professional development, particularly in fields requiring practical wisdom rather than just theoretical knowledge. It's useful when mentoring junior colleagues, encouraging a growth mindset, or explaining why 'failure' is a critical part of the learning curve. You could cite it when justifying experimental approaches, reflecting on past mistakes during a project debrief, or motivating someone who is feeling disheartened by an error. It also serves as a reminder that patience and resilience are paramount in the journey towards mastery and competence.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Will Rogers suggests that good judgment is the outcome of experience, and a significant portion of that experience comes from making bad judgments and learning from them.

    According to Will Rogers' perspective, wisdom is not an innate gift but is earned through a process of trial and error, essentially recycling one's own failures.

    The quote implies that failure is not an endpoint but the essential raw material required to build future success and competence.

    This quote acts as an antidote to perfectionism by reframing mistakes and missteps as necessary steps, or 'tuition payments,' for developing future competence and good judgment.

    Sources & References